countyDutchess County Legislature
2026030
OPPOSING THE PROPOSED FEDERAL IMMIGRATION DETENTION FACILITY IN THE TOWN OF CHESTER, ORANGE COUNTY, DUE TO SERIOUS CONCERNS REGARDING DUE PROCESS, TRHE RULE OF LAW, LACK OF TRANSPANENCY, AND UNDETERMINED FISCAL , ENVIORNMENTAL
- Introduced
- March 8, 2026
- Latest action
- March 8, 2026
- Status
- ADOPTED
- District coverage
- scope: countywide
Document text
Extracted from the official document; OCR may contain errors.
PUBLIC SAFETY
RESOLUTION NO. 2026030
RE: OPPOSING THE PROPOSED FEDERAL IMMIGRATION DETENTION
FACILITY IN THE TOWN OF CHESTER, ORANGE COUNTY, DUE TO SERIOUS
CONCERNS REGARDING DUE PROCESS, THE RULE OF LAW, LACK OF
IRANSPARENCY, AND UNDETERMINED FISCAL, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND HUMAN
RIGHTS IMPACTS AND REAFFIRMING DUTCHESS COUNTY AS A WELCOMING
COMMUNITY FOR ALL
Legislators_ SHAH, KAUL, DRAGO, VALDÉS SMITH, ATKINS, MUNN,
ALEXANDER, ARNOFF, BRENDLI, KEARNEY, LAWLER, REDL, RHODES and WINSBY
offer the following resolution:
WHEREAS, since its founding, Dutchess County has been a strong, stable, and welcoming
community, enriched by the contributions of individuals from every race, background, religion,
creed, and national origin, including immigrants and families who live, work, raise children, and
contribute meaningfully to the County's economic, agricultural, and civic life; and
WHEREAS, in recent years, Dutchess County has witnessed troubling public examples of
hate and intimidation directed at individuals and groups, including immigrants, based on
religion, national origin, or status; and
WHEREAS, such hate, discrimination, and bigotry are inconsistent with the values of the
Dutchess County Legislature, Dutchess County Government, and the residents of the County; and
WHEREAS, the Dutchess County Legislature continues to denounce and condemn hate,
discrimination, and bigotry in all forms and reaffirms its commitment to fostering a
welcoming, safe, and inclusive community for all residents; and
WHEREAS, the Legislature recognizes that fear, intimidation, and hostility
against immigrants undermine community safety, destabilize families, hurts our local economy,
especially small businesses, and erodes trust in public institutions; and
WHEREAS, the Dutchess County Legislature is committed to public safety, the rule of
law, accountable government, and the protection of strong families and healthy communities; and
WHEREAS, the United States Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and
Customs Enforcement have proposed a federal immigration detention or processing facility in
the Town of Chester, Orange County, New York; and
WHEREAS, large-scale civil detention or processing facilities have foreseeable regional
impacts, including human, environmental, fiscal, and infrastructure demands that extend
beyond the host municipality and directly affect neighboring counties, including Dutchess
County; and
WHEREAS, recent federal immigration enforcement practices have raised concerns
regarding human rights, due process, access to counsel, public safety, continuity of medical and
mental health care, and the stability of families and communities that rely on County-
based services; and
WHEREAS, the proposed detention or processing facility in the Town of Chester would
present foreseeable regional impacts for Dutchess County, including potential strain on hospitals,
emergency medical services, housing resources, mental health providers, social service agencies,
legal systems, shared environmental resources, and as the closest proposed facility to Dutchess
County it is the likeliest place where our residents would be housed; and
WHEREAS, responsible governance requires transparency, advance notice, and
meaningful intergovernmental coordination so that counties may assess, plan for, and mitigate
impacts on residents and public systems; and
WHEREAS, to date, sufficient information regarding the scope, capacity, operations,
infrastructure demands, detention standards, environmental impacts, and compliance with state
and local law of the proposed facility has not been provided to affected regional governments; and
WHEREAS, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation has identified
unresolved concerns involving floodplains, wetlands, stormwater management, wastewater
capacity, and tributaries connected to the Hudson River watershed, and has determined that
available materials are insufficient for meaningful environmental review; and
WHEREAS, Dutchess County has previously experienced unanticipated demands on
healthcare systems, housing resources, legal service providers, and community organizations when
large-scale governmental actions proceeded without adequate coordination resulting in emergency
executive orders; and
WHEREAS, Dutchess County holds a unique place in constitutional history as the site of
New York State's ratification of the United States Constitution, and its elected officials are sworn
to uphold principles of due process, accountability, transparency, and the rule of law;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Dutchess County Legislature
denounces and condemns hate, discrimination, intimidation, and bigotry in all of their
manifestations, including hate directed at immigrants, and reaffirms its commitment to maintaining
a welcoming, safe, and inclusive County for all residents; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Legislature finds that large-scale governmental actions that increase
fear, destabilize families, or strain County systems undermine community safety and cohesion
within Dutchess County; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Dutchess County Legislature hereby opposes the proposed federal
immigration detention or processing facility in the Town of Chester, Orange County, based on its
foreseeable regional impacts on Dutchess County, including risks to public health, environmental
resources, infrastructure capacity, emergency services, social service systems, and community
stability; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Legislature finds that the proposed facility, as currently presented,
lacks sufficient transparency, advance notice, and meaningful intergovernmental coordination
necessary for affected counties to adequately assess, plan for, and mitigate its regional impacts;
and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Legislature reaffirms its obligation to uphold constitutional
principles, including due process, accountability, transparency, and the rule of law, and to
safeguard the health, safety, and welfare of Dutchess County residents through responsible
planning and sound governance.
APPROVED
SUSAN J. SERINO
COUNTY EXECUTIVE
Data Marh 122026
STATE OF NEW YORK
SS:
COUNTY OF DUTCHESS
his is to certify that I, the undersigned Clerk of the Legislature of the County of Dutchess, have compared the foregoing resolution with the origina
esolution now on file in the office of said clerk, and which was adopted by said Lepislature on the
-day of fund 2024 and that the same is a true and
correct transcript of said original resolution and of the whole thereof.
IN WITNESS WHEREO, I have hereunto set my hand and seal of said legislate this I day of Moth 2026.
JULIE SMIROISHI, CLERK OF THE LEGISLATURE
Roll Call Sheets
District
Present:
Absent:
Vacant:
Last Name
YES
District 16 - Fishkill and Beacon
Valdés Smith
District 9 - City of Poughkeepsie
Atkins
District 20 - Red Hook, Tivoli, and Rhinebeck
Munn
District 3 - LaGrange
Polasek
District 12 - East Fishkill
Metzger
District 1 - Town of Poughkeepsie
Redl
/
District 2 - LaGrange, Pleasant Valley & Town of Poughkeepsie
Arnoff
District 4 - Hyde Park and Town of Poughkeepsie
Lawler
District 5 - Town of Poughkeepsie
Shah
District 6 - Town of Poughkeepsie
Kaul
District 7 - Hyde Park and Pleasant Valley
Darrow
District 8 - City and Town of Poughkeepsie
Brendli
District 10 - City of Poughkeepsie
Johnson
District 11 - Clinton, Pleasant Valley, and Rhinebeck
Kearney
District 13 - East Fishkill and Wappinger
Giles
District 14 - Wappinger and Town of Poughkeepsie
Winsby
District 15 - Wappinger
Faust
District 17 - Town and Village of Fishkill
McHoul
District 18 - City of Beacon and Fishkill
Rhodes
District 19 - North East, Stanford, Pine Plains, Milan & Red Hook
Drago
District 21 - East Fishkill
Caswell
District 22 - Beekman and Union Vale
Tresca
District 23 - Pawling, Beekman and East Fishkill
District 24 - Dover and Pawling
Rolison
House
District 25 - Amenia, Washington, Pleasant Valley & Millbrook Alexander
Resolution:
Motion:
Atkins/Muns
Total :
20
Yes
Abstentions:
NO
absent
absent
absent
absent
absent
No
2026030 OPPOSING THE PROPOSED FEDERAL IMMIGRATION DETENTION
FACILITY IN THE TOWN OF CHESTER, ORANGE COUNTY, DUE TO SERIOUS
CONCERNS REGARDING DUE PROCESS, THE RULE OF LAW, LACK OF
TRANSPARENCY, AND UNDETERMINED FISCAL, ENVIONMENTAL, AND HUMAN
RIGHTS IMPACTS AND REAFFIRIMING DUTCHESS COUNTY AS A WELCOMING
COMMUNITY FOR ALL
FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
X NO FISCAL IMPACT PROJECTED
APPROPRIATION RESOLUTIONS
(To be completed by requesting department)
Total Current Year Cost $ .
Total Current Year Revenue $
and Source
Source of County Funds (check one): |
L Existing Appropriations,
•Contingency,
L Transfer of Existing Appropriations, • Additional Appropriations, • Other (explain).
Identify Line Items(s):
Related Expenses: Amount $
Nature/Reason:
Anticipated Savings to County:
Net County Cost (this year):
Over Five Years:
Additional Comments/Explanation:
Prepared by:
Prepared On:
Dutpo
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
ABSENT
X
X
X
X
11
11
1
2026030 OPPOSING THE PROPOSED FEDERAL IMMIGRATION DETENTION
FACILITY IN THE TOWN OF CHESTER, ORANGE COUNTY, DUE TO SERIOUS
CONCERNS REGARDING DUE PROCESS, THE RULE OF LAW, LACK OF
TRANSPARENCY, AND UNDETERMINED FISCAL, ENVIONMENTAL, AND HUMAN
RIGHTS IMPACTS AND REAFFIRIMING DUTCHESS COUNTY AS A WELCOMING
COMMUNITY FOR ALL
Roll Call Sheets
District Last Name YES NO
District 16 - Fishkill and Beacon Valdés Smith
District 9 - City of Poughkeepsie Atkins
District 20 - Red Hook, Tivoli, and Rhinebeck Munn
District 3 - LaGrange Polasek
District 12 - East Fishkill Metzger
District 1 - Town of Poughkeepsie Redl
District 2 - LaGrange, Pleasant Valley & Town of Poughkeepsie Arnoff
District 4 - Hyde Park and Town of Poughkeepsie Lawler
District 5 - Town of Poughkeepsie Shah
District 6 - Town of Poughkeepsie Kaul
District 7 - Hyde Park and Pleasant Valley Darrow
District 8 - City and Town of Poughkeepsie Brendli
District 10 - City of Poughkeepsie Johnson
District 11 - Clinton, Pleasant Valley, and Rhinebeck Kearney
District 13 - East Fishkill and Wappinger Giles
District 14 - Wappinger and Town of Poughkeepsie Winsby
District 15 - Wappinger Faust
District 17 - Town and Village of Fishkill McHoul
District 18 - City of Beacon and Fishkill Rhodes
District 19 - North East, Stanford, Pine Plains, Milan & Red Hook Drago
District 21 - East Fishkill Caswell
District 22 - Beekman and Union Vale Tresca
District 23 - Pawling, Beekman and East Fishkill Rolison
District 24 - Dover and Pawling House
District 25 - Amenia, Washington, Pleasant Valley & Millbrook Alexander
X
X
X
ABSENT
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
ABSENT
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
ABSENT
ABSENT
ABSENT
20
Present: ____
5
Absent: ____
Vacant: ____
Resolution: ____
Motion: ____
20
Total : ______ ______
Yes No
Abstentions: ____
2026030 OPPOSING THE PROPOSED FEDERAL IMMIGRATION DETENTION
FACILITY IN THE TOWN OF CHESTER, ORANGE COUNTY, DUE TO SERIOUS
CONCERNS REGARDING DUE PROCESS, THE RULE OF LAW, LACK OF
TRANSPARENCY, AND UNDETERMINED FISCAL, ENVIONMENTAL, AND HUMAN
RIGHTS IMPACTS AND REAFFIRIMING DUTCHESS COUNTY AS A WELCOMING
COMMUNITY FOR ALL